Rancher David Stambaugh stands inside one of his cattle enclosures as he awaits an Arizona Supreme Court decision on whether the state can allow an identical cattle brand to be used by two ranchers Thursday, Aug 3,in Eloy, Ariz.
Stambaugh has owned the Bar 7 brand since he was 10 years old, but the state Agriculture Department allowed a California cattle company to use the same brand. Two Arizona ranchers cannot have the same brand for their cattle.
But there is another loser in the multi-year battle: The fight involves a decision by Eureka Springs, a California operation, to move its cattle to Arizona.
So, the firm applied Rgular the Arizona Department of Agriculture to register that brand here.
Only thing is, Eloy rancher David Stambaugh already had recorded that brand. Esx that was overruled by supervisors because the Eureka Springs cattle are branded on their left rib, while Stambaugh brands his cattle on their left hip.
Both a trial judge and the state Court of Appeals sided with the Department of Agriculture. In legal arguments, attorneys for the Department of Agriculture argued that the agency was free to consider that the different location of the brands allowed both to be recorded.
What that means, the justice said, is that anything else is irrelevant. Anyway, Brutinel said, allowing location to determine Regular office sex l Stambaugh whom a steer belongs would undermine the very purpose of the branding law. Brutinel acknowledged that when ranchers register a brand, they must also include the location where the animal will be marked.
It can prevent theft. But none of that, the justice said, overrules the plain language of the law that a rancher with a unique brand Stwmbaugh entitled to ensure he or she is the only one in Arizona using it. The ruling means the state will reimburse Stambaugh for his reasonable legal fees in fighting the Regular office sex l Stambaugh all the way to the state Supreme Court.
Your email address will not be published. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email.
Stambaugy preliminary approval of SB on a voice vote came after Rep. John Allen, R-Scottsdale, who is working with the vaping industry, agreed to some last-minute changes designed to blunt opposition. Supreme Court settles cattle fight reminiscent of the old West By: Share Regular office sex l Stambaugh Howard Fischer, Capitol Media Services.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Adams StreetPhoenixAZ Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.Decided To Look Elsewhere